SQL Server Dynamic Data Masking not working. Are you using the correct role permissions?

You have implemented the Dynamic Date Masking (DDM) in your SQL Database, but still you get the unmasked data. Are you using the correct role permissions and the correct logins?

I published a post before the general availability (GA) of DDM about what you need to know about the DDM GA.

There were two key points were highlighted about the DDM GA. They were

  • SQL Logins will be removed from the exclusion list and you have to specify the SQL users or Azure AD users directly in the exclusion list.
  • SQL users with administrative privileges are always excluded from dynamic data masking

I have mentioned those in the published article as well, the issue is at the time of that writing db_owner permissions also see the masked data, but recently I noted that db_owner can see the data unmasked. Data is only masked for the data_reader.

So if you’re seeing the unmasked data make sure, to use data_reader permissions to the users from whom you want to mask the data.

The issue is user with administrative privileges includes the db_owner as well, but I still have concerns on this, where we do not generally consider db_owner as an admin level permission.

I’m in some disucssions with the Microsoft internals regarding this change and told this change was made right before the GA. The documenations of DDM do not explain this. I will do the comments under this post if any interesting news come in.

Advertisement

What you need to know about SQL Database Dynamic Data Masking before the GA

Please read this post after reading this, as some critical changes have gone to the DDM feature of SQL Databases in GA
SQL Database Dynamic Data Masking will be Generally Available (GA) very soon by the end of this month.

For more information about Dynamic Database Masking please read this article.

As per the article you can configure the dynamic data masking on columns which have sensitive data, and also we have the options to specify the SQL Logins which should be excluded from masking. Meaning any user connecting to the database using the specified SQL login will see the data without being masked.

  • SQL Logins will be removed from the exclusion list and you have to specify the SQL users or Azure AD users directly in the exclusion list.
  • SQL users with administrative privileges are always excluded from dynamic data masking

Example:

In a SQL Database server with a SQL Database named Db1 there are 3 SQL logins.

SQL Login

SQL user

Privilege

thuru Thuru Admin (sa) for the server
login1 User1 db_owner for Db1
login2 User2 db_owner for Db1

First thing to note is, after the GA of the feature you cannot user SQL login names in the exclusion list in the portal meaning that you cannot specify login1, login2 in the list. Instead of specifying the SQL login you should specify the SQL users as user1, user2.

And SQL users who have administrative privileges always see the data.

Look at the image below as I have specified only user1 in the exclusion list.

Login to the database as thuru and executing a SELECT statement results this.

As you see, though I haven’t specified the admin user in the exclusion list, still admins are automatically excluded from dynamic data masking. If you’re using admin users in your application and enabled dynamic data masking, you have to create other SQL logins to access the database.

Login to the database as user1 and user2 outputs the following results respectively.

How to create other SQL Logins in SQL Database

Login to the server using the admin user.

  1. Select the master database and create the logins using this command.

  2. Connect to the database you want to add the user to and add the user using the created SQL login in step 1

  3. Add roles to the user